Your Marketing Isn’t Broken — Your Shop Is

Confession No. 128 · Marketing Call #3 · November 17, 2026 · 48 min.

Listen Now · No. 128

0:0047:30

About This Episode

From Our Sponsors

  • Tektonic 2027 is coming up April 1-3, and if you missed year 1, you MUST NOT miss year 2. It's bigger, it's better, because is Tekmetric's conference. You know it's gonna be the best conference in the history of conferences. Get lower pricing now HERE about Tekmetric

  • Turnkey Marketing takes the stress of doing something I'm not good at off my plate. And gives it to someone who is. Click HERE about Turnkey Marketing for more.

  • 47 Consultants brings your shop’s story to life on social media, helping Carfix engage 60,000 people in Raleigh in just a few weeks. See what 47 Consultants can do for your shop, and tell them Big Daddy Mike sent you!

  • Elite Worldwide's Ignite 2027 is coming up in February and NOW is the time to sign up. It's happening in Vegas February 4-6 and it will be the best 3 days of your shops year when you attend. Save $100 when you use code CONFESSIONS HERE about Elite Worldwide

  • When I used the maintenance tool for the first time with Detect Auto, my mind was blown. My advisors had the same reaction - and then SO MUCH MORE TIME. Learn more about Detect Auto and book a free demo now!

What happens when your marketing is actually working — but your shop still isn’t getting enough cars through the door? Carry-Lynn Rodenberg from Turnkey Marketing joins Mike Allen for a real-world breakdown of Mike’s shop numbers, including leads, conversion rates, car count, ARO, revenue, marketing spend, and what those numbers actually mean when you put them in context. They dig into why shops in growth mode have to spend differently than shops in maintenance mode, why more leads won’t solve a bad phone process, and how a business can actually be healthier with lower revenue if profitability improves. Carry-Lynn also explains why your true competition may not be the shops you think it is, how increasingly targeted digital marketing can reach customers across email, streaming platforms, and connected devices, and why Mike isn’t quite ready for Turnkey’s DirectTrack strategy yet. Plus, they talk email collection, Google reviews, aggressive oil-change offers, and the uncomfortable reality that two out of three shops blaming their marketing may actually have a sales problem instead.

704-CONFESS

The Confession Line

Questions, feedback, a confession of your own, or a little trash talk. Call the line and say it.

Listen on Your Platform

Order of Proceedings